
Hotel Gettysburg
Best for history-focused stays, downtown walkability, and on-site event or wedding venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Gettysburg is a restored 1797 landmark on Lincoln Square with 119 rooms, on-site American dining (One Lincoln), event space, and a 24-hour fitness center—good for history-minded sightseers, meetings, and weddings. Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield is a midscale Choice-branded hotel at 380 Steinwehr Ave with 109 rooms, indoor and seasonal outdoor pools, and free breakfast—best for practical, sightseeing-focused visitors who want straightforward amenities near battlefield sites.
Updated

Best for history-focused stays, downtown walkability, and on-site event or wedding venues.

Best for budget-minded battlefield sightseeing with pool access and complimentary breakfast.
When Hotel Gettysburg wins: choose Hotel Gettysburg if you want to stay in a historic, central downtown building with an on-site full-service restaurant, Starbucks, extensive meeting and wedding space, and a fireplace lobby. It’s the stronger pick for event planners and guests who value downtown walkability and historic character.
When Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield wins: choose the Quality Inn if you want a recognizable, budget-oriented brand with easy battlefield proximity, a small fitness center, an indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool, free buffet breakfast, and free self parking. It’s practical for sightseeing-focused travelers who prefer included breakfast and pool access.
Bottom line: Hotel Gettysburg is the better choice for downtown ambiance, dining, and event space; Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield is the better-value, amenity-forward option for travelers prioritizing a pool and complimentary breakfast near battlefield sites.
| Category | Hotel Gettysburg | Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown landmark with period features and event spaces | Practical, branded midscale hotel focused on sightseeing convenience |
| Location | One Lincoln Square — fronts Lincoln Square in downtown Gettysburg, immediate walkability to shops and museums | 380 Steinwehr Ave — centrally located, listed as a short walk to Gettysburg National Military Park |
| Size (rooms) | 119 guest rooms | 109 guest rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; lead guest minimum-age listed as 21 on third-party sites | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools / signature amenity | No on-site swimming pool (hotel FAQ) | Indoor pool plus seasonal outdoor pool (listed facilities) |
| Restaurants & bars | One Lincoln (American casual-comfort) + full-service Starbucks café; bar adjoins One Lincoln | Complimentary buffet breakfast; bar/lounge listed among amenities |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center; no on-site spa published | Fitness facilities listed; no on-site spa published |
| Known for | Historic ballroom and wedding/event venues, downtown location | Close access to Gettysburg National Military Park and battlefield-focused name |
| Parking | Self-parking available in adjacent Borough garage (paid) | Free self parking on site |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Complimentary wireless internet throughout | |
Hotel Gettysburg sits on Lincoln Square in the heart of downtown, steps from historic sites and shops.
Pick Hotel Gettysburg for downtown walkability and immediate access to Lincoln Square attractions.
Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield is centrally located on Steinwehr Ave with short walks to battlefield-related sites.
Choose Quality Inn for straightforward battlefield access and a central, practical location.
Hotel Gettysburg’s 119 rooms include traditional rooms and multiple suite types, some with Jacuzzi tubs or gas fireplaces.
Hotel Gettysburg is the better choice if you want historic character or suites with fireplaces/Jacuzzis.
Quality Inn offers a variety of midscale room types with standard in-room conveniences.
Quality Inn is a practical option if you want simple, functional rooms with in-room fridges and microwaves.
Hotel Gettysburg houses One Lincoln (American casual-comfort) and an on-site full-service Starbucks.
If an on-site full-service restaurant and Starbucks matter, Hotel Gettysburg is the stronger pick.
Quality Inn emphasizes convenience dining with a complimentary buffet breakfast and an on‑site bar/lounge.
Quality Inn is tuned to guests who value a complimentary breakfast and basic evening drinks on site.
Hotel Gettysburg’s official information states there is no on-site swimming pool.
Do not expect pool access at Hotel Gettysburg—plan for fitness center use instead.
Quality Inn lists both an indoor pool and an outdoor seasonal pool among its guest amenities.
Quality Inn is the clear choice for travelers who want pool access during their stay.
Hotel Gettysburg offers a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site bar adjoining One Lincoln.
Hotel Gettysburg suits guests who want a gym plus downtown evening options in walking distance.
Quality Inn lists fitness facilities and a bar/lounge; nearby attractions provide evening options.
Quality Inn covers basic wellness needs and gives easy access to nearby evening dining and entertainment.

Hotel Gettysburg — historic building on Lincoln Square, on-site American dining, and character-filled event spaces.

Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield — indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool listed for guest use.

Hotel Gettysburg — large Grand Ballroom and multiple dedicated meeting/wedding rooms with historic features.

Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield — Choice-brand convenience, free buffet breakfast, and free self parking.
Hotel Gettysburg sits on Lincoln Square in downtown and offers immediate walkability; Quality Inn is centrally located on Steinwehr Ave with short walks to battlefield-adjacent sites.
Quality Inn Gettysburg Battlefield lists an indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool; Hotel Gettysburg’s official information states it does not have a swimming pool.
Quality Inn advertises a complimentary buffet breakfast. Hotel Gettysburg offers breakfast at One Lincoln for an additional charge; breakfast is not included in standard room rates.
Hotel Gettysburg — it has a historic Grand Ballroom, multiple meeting rooms, and large total meeting/event space suited to weddings and conferences.
Explore how Hotel Gettysburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·