
Hotel Gettysburg
Best for travelers who want historic charm, a large event/wedding space, and a convenient spot on Lincoln Square.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Gettysburg is a restored, historic 119-room downtown hotel on Lincoln Square with on-site dining, meeting space and a 24-hour fitness center — good for visitors who want central walkability and event facilities. Inn at Cemetery Hill is a modest, recognizable budget-friendly inn on Baltimore Street near Cemetery Hill, aimed at travelers who prioritize proximity to battlefield sites and pet-friendly value.
Updated · about 0.4 km apart (roughly 0.25 miles)

Best for travelers who want historic charm, a large event/wedding space, and a convenient spot on Lincoln Square.

Best for budget-minded visitors who want an affordable, central base steps from Cemetery Hill and many downtown attractions, especially if traveling with pets.
When Hotel Gettysburg wins: choose Hotel Gettysburg if you want a larger, historic property with an on-site restaurant (One Lincoln), a full-service Starbucks, more meeting and wedding space, and the convenience of Lincoln Square for walkable downtown dining and museums.
When Inn at Cemetery Hill wins: pick Inn at Cemetery Hill if you need a budget-friendly, pet-friendly option very close to Cemetery Hill and other battlefield sites, or if complimentary grab-and-go breakfast and free parking are priorities.
Bottom line: Hotel Gettysburg is the higher-capacity, historic downtown option for guests who value restaurants and event venues; Inn at Cemetery Hill is a simpler, value-oriented alternative with strong battlefield proximity and pet-friendly rooms.
| Category | Hotel Gettysburg | Inn at Cemetery Hill |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic downtown landmark with event spaces and full-service dining | Recognizable budget-friendly inn focused on convenience and value |
| Location | One Lincoln Square — on Lincoln Square in central downtown Gettysburg | 613 Baltimore St — central Gettysburg, 0.1 mi from Cemetery Hill |
| Size | 119 guest rooms, multiple suites and meeting rooms | 51 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; main booker minimum age listed as 21 on some third-party sites | All-ages; no adults-only policy |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool (hotel FAQ) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | One Lincoln (American casual-comfort) + on-site Starbucks | No on-site signature restaurant listed; complimentary on-the-go breakfast |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center available | Not published |
| Known for | Historic architecture, ballroom and meeting/wedding venues | Close walking access to Cemetery Hill and battlefield points; pet-friendly rooms |
| Parking | Paid self-parking in an adjacent Borough garage (not a hotel-owned lot) | Free self parking and free RV/bus/truck parking onsite |
| Accessibility | Handicap accessible; 12 ADA-compliant rooms | Multiple wheelchair-accessible features (parking, paths, elevator) |
Hotel Gettysburg sits directly on Lincoln Square in the heart of downtown, steps from city museums and theaters.
Choose Hotel Gettysburg for the busiest downtown location and immediate walkability.
Inn at Cemetery Hill is on Baltimore Street a short walk from Cemetery Hill and other battlefield sites.
Choose Inn at Cemetery Hill if you want to be extremely close to battlefield landmarks on a budget.
Hotel Gettysburg offers 119 rooms and suites with some rooms featuring Jacuzzi tubs and gas fireplaces.
Hotel Gettysburg provides room variety and a few higher-end touches suitable for couples and events.
Inn at Cemetery Hill has 51 individually decorated guestrooms, many explicitly listed as pet friendly.
Inn at Cemetery Hill is a straightforward, pet-friendly choice with practical room amenities and many pet-designated room types.
Hotel Gettysburg has an on-site restaurant and a full-service Starbucks for more flexible dining.
Hotel Gettysburg is better if you want seated restaurant dining and a coffee shop on the property.
Inn at Cemetery Hill offers a complimentary to-go breakfast and relies on nearby downtown dining for other meals.
Inn at Cemetery Hill suits guests who prefer quick breakfast and plan to eat around downtown.
Hotel Gettysburg emphasizes historic event spaces and a 24-hour fitness center rather than pool amenities.
Hotel Gettysburg is geared toward events and staying active, not poolside leisure.
Inn at Cemetery Hill highlights convenience features like free self parking and battlefield proximity.
Inn at Cemetery Hill is practical: easy parking and quick access to battlefield sites, not resort-style amenities.
Hotel Gettysburg provides a 24-hour fitness center and a central bar/restaurant for evening drinks or meals.
Hotel Gettysburg is a better pick for guests who want evening dining and an on-site fitness room.
Inn at Cemetery Hill is a quieter, budget-oriented lodging close to daytime battlefield activities.
Inn at Cemetery Hill fits travelers focused on daytime touring and a straightforward place to return to at night.

Hotel Gettysburg — large historic Grand Ballroom, multiple event rooms, and full wedding packages.

Inn at Cemetery Hill — very close to Cemetery Hill and easy walking access to several battlefield-related sites.

Hotel Gettysburg — One Lincoln restaurant plus an on-site full-service Starbucks.

Inn at Cemetery Hill — many explicitly pet-friendly room types and value-focused amenities including free parking.
Inn at Cemetery Hill — the supplier listing notes it is about 0.1 mi (0.2 km) from Cemetery Hill; Hotel Gettysburg is a short walk to other downtown landmarks but slightly farther from Cemetery Hill.
Hotel Gettysburg's FAQ states there is no on-site swimming pool; Inn at Cemetery Hill's supplier listing does not publish a pool detail.
Inn at Cemetery Hill is pet friendly (many room types explicitly list 'Pet Friendly'); Hotel Gettysburg does not allow pets except service animals.
Hotel Gettysburg — it has extensive meeting space, a historic Grand Ballroom and multiple venue rooms suitable for weddings and conferences.
Explore how Hotel Gettysburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·