
Hotel Gettysburg
Best for travelers who want central downtown location, on-site restaurant and substantial meeting/wedding space.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Gettysburg is a 119-room historic downtown hotel on Lincoln Square with on-site dining, a 24-hour fitness center and event space; read this if you want easy access to Gettysburg’s shops, restaurants and battlefield attractions. Baladerry Inn is a small, highly rated 3-star bed & breakfast near the Gettysburg battlefield; read this if you prefer a quieter, personal B&B experience with included local breakfast.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want central downtown location, on-site restaurant and substantial meeting/wedding space.

Best for travelers who prefer a small-inn atmosphere, personalized service and a complimentary local-cuisine breakfast.
When Hotel Gettysburg wins: choose Hotel Gettysburg if you want to be in the heart of town with walkable access to Lincoln Square attractions, need larger event or meeting space, or prefer an on-site American restaurant and a 24-hour fitness center.
When Baladerry Inn wins: choose Baladerry Inn for a quieter, more intimate stay at a small inn with individually decorated rooms, a hot tub/sauna and a complimentary local-cuisine breakfast included each morning.
Bottom line: Hotel Gettysburg suits visitors who want downtown convenience, dining and substantial event facilities; Baladerry Inn suits couples or small groups seeking a boutique B&B feel and included breakfast close to battlefield sites.
| Category | Hotel Gettysburg | Baladerry Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, larger downtown hotel with formal event spaces and public dining | Small, guesthouse-style bed & breakfast with personalized service |
| Location | On Lincoln Square in central Gettysburg; steps to downtown sights | 40 Hospital Rd, close to Gettysburg National Military Park and within a short drive of visitor center |
| Size | 119 guest rooms | 11 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; lead guest typically must be 21+ to check in | All ages welcome (no adults-only policy) |
| Pools / hot tubs | No on-site swimming pool per hotel's FAQ | Hot tub and sauna on site |
| Restaurants & bars | One Lincoln (American casual-comfort) and on-site Starbucks | Complimentary local-cuisine breakfast daily; no full-service on-site restaurant listed |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa name or treatments published | Spa services on site plus sauna and hot tub |
| Known for | Historic ballroom and extensive meeting/wedding venues | High guest rating (9.8) and bed & breakfast atmosphere |
| Parking | Paid public self-parking garage adjacent to the hotel (fee) | Free self parking (uncovered) on site |
| Free breakfast | Breakfast available on-site for an extra charge | Complimentary local-cuisine breakfast served daily 8:00–9:00 AM |
Hotel Gettysburg sits on Lincoln Square in the center of downtown Gettysburg, steps from historic sites and local shops.
Choose Hotel Gettysburg for the most central, walkable downtown location.
Baladerry Inn has an address on Hospital Road and is close to battlefield points and golf attractions, offering quieter surroundings than the downtown core.
Choose Baladerry Inn for a quieter base that’s still convenient to battlefield sites.
Hotel Gettysburg is a larger, historic property with a range of room types and several suites.
Hotel Gettysburg offers scale and variety in room types for larger parties and events.
Baladerry Inn provides a small selection of individually decorated rooms and a few named suites.
Baladerry Inn is best if you want a small, characterful room rather than a standardized hotel layout.
Hotel Gettysburg hosts One Lincoln for American casual-comfort dining plus an on-site Starbucks.
Hotel Gettysburg is convenient if you want full-service on-site dining and a Starbucks.
Baladerry Inn focuses on breakfast as a core guest offering rather than a full-service restaurant.
Baladerry Inn is best if an included morning breakfast is important to you.
Hotel Gettysburg’s signature offering is its historic event and meeting space.
Hotel Gettysburg is a natural choice for weddings, conferences and larger gatherings.
Baladerry Inn emphasizes small-inn amenities and on-site recreational features.
Baladerry Inn suits travelers who prefer on-property leisure amenities in a small setting.
Hotel Gettysburg offers a 24-hour fitness center and downtown nightlife within walking distance.
Pick Hotel Gettysburg for a full-time fitness room and easy access to downtown evening options.
Baladerry Inn provides on-site spa-related amenities and quieter evening options.
Baladerry Inn is better if on-site hot tub/sauna and a relaxed evening atmosphere matter to you.

Hotel Gettysburg — immediate walkability to Lincoln Square shops, theater and museums.

Baladerry Inn — small number of individually decorated rooms and included local breakfast.

Hotel Gettysburg — large Grand Ballroom, multiple meeting rooms and comprehensive wedding packages.

Baladerry Inn — hot tub, sauna, pickleball court and garden/terrace spaces for relaxation.
Hotel Gettysburg. It sits on Lincoln Square within easy walking distance of downtown shops, the Majestic Theater and nearby dining.
Yes — Baladerry Inn serves a complimentary local-cuisine breakfast daily from 8:00–9:00 AM.
Hotel Gettysburg’s own FAQ states there is no on-site swimming pool; no on-site spa name or treatments are published.
Hotel Gettysburg — it offers a historic Grand Ballroom and nearly 9,700 sq ft of meeting/event space and formal wedding packages.
Explore how Hotel Gettysburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·