
Hotel Gettysburg
Best for travelers who want a historic downtown stay within walking distance of Lincoln Square attractions and on-site dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Gettysburg is a restored 1797 landmark on Lincoln Square with on-site American dining and meeting space; read this if you want a historic, downtown base for sightseeing or events. Best Western Gettysburg is a centrally located, branded budget hotel near battlefield attractions; read this if you prefer a well-known chain, free breakfast, and straightforward amenities.
Updated · about 0.2 mi apart

Best for travelers who want a historic downtown stay within walking distance of Lincoln Square attractions and on-site dining.

Best for travelers who want a recognizable brand, free full breakfast, and basic on-site fitness and pool facilities near the battlefield.
When Hotel Gettysburg wins: choose Hotel Gettysburg if you want a central, historic address on Lincoln Square, an on-site restaurant and Starbucks, and extensive event/wedding venues — ideal for visitors who value atmosphere and walkability.
When Best Western Gettysburg wins: choose Best Western Gettysburg if you want a consistent branded experience, complimentary full breakfast, an indoor pool and free parking on site, and very direct access to battlefield attractions.
Bottom line: pick Hotel Gettysburg for history, downtown dining and event space; pick Best Western Gettysburg for chain-standard amenities, complimentary breakfast, and an indoor pool close to the park.
| Category | Hotel Gettysburg | Best Western Gettysburg |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown landmark with classic public spaces | Practical, branded midscale hotel focused on convenience |
| Location | One Lincoln Square — in the heart of downtown Gettysburg, steps from Lincoln Square | 301 Steinwehr Avenue — centrally located, steps from Gettysburg National Military Park |
| Size (guest rooms) | 119 guest rooms | 81 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Age / style | Restored 1797 building with historical interiors | Modern branded hotel (Best Western) — mid- to late-20th-century construction typical of chains |
| Pools | No on-site pool (hotel FAQ states none) | Indoor pool (listed in supplier amenities) |
| Restaurants & bars | One Lincoln (American comfort) plus full-service Starbucks | Complimentary full breakfast daily; no named signature restaurant published |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa published | |
| Fitness | 24-hour fitness center | Fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Historic rooms, ballroom and wedding/event venues on Lincoln Square | Branded value stay with free breakfast and proximity to battlefield sites |
| Parking | Paid self-parking in adjacent Borough garage (no private lot) | Free self parking on-site (listed) |
Hotel Gettysburg sits directly on Lincoln Square, putting downtown sights and nearby museums within easy walking distance.
Stay here if you want to be in the middle of downtown Gettysburg with pedestrian access to local attractions.
Best Western Gettysburg is positioned on Steinwehr Avenue, close to battlefield attractions and short drives to the Visitor Center.
Choose Best Western Gettysburg if proximity to battlefield sites and chain-brand predictability matter most.
Hotel Gettysburg offers 119 rooms and suites with select rooms featuring fireplaces or Jacuzzi tubs.
If you want historic-room character and larger suites for events or families, Hotel Gettysburg provides more variety.
Best Western Gettysburg has 81 individually decorated guestrooms with standard midscale amenities.
Choose Best Western for consistent, accessible rooms with in-room microwaves/refrigerators and chain-standard conveniences.
Hotel Gettysburg has an on-site restaurant and a full-service Starbucks adjoining the lobby.
If you prefer on-site restaurant dining, a hotel bar and a Starbucks all within one property, Hotel Gettysburg fits that need.
Best Western Gettysburg highlights a complimentary full breakfast and basic dining conveniences.
Best Western is a practical pick when a complimentary breakfast and simple in-room food options matter.
Hotel Gettysburg's official materials state there is no on-site swimming pool.
Don’t expect an on-site pool at Hotel Gettysburg based on the hotel’s official information.
Best Western Gettysburg lists an indoor pool among its amenities.
If an indoor pool is important, Best Western Gettysburg publishes one; Hotel Gettysburg does not.
Hotel Gettysburg provides a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site bar connected to One Lincoln.
Hotel Gettysburg suits guests looking for a full downtown evening and reliable fitness options.
Best Western Gettysburg includes fitness facilities and basic concierge services.
Best Western covers essential wellness and service needs with a focus on convenience rather than nightlife.

Hotel Gettysburg — stays on Lincoln Square with historic public rooms, an on-site restaurant and Starbucks.

Best Western Gettysburg — complimentary full breakfast daily and an indoor pool listed in amenities.

Hotel Gettysburg — large Grand Ballroom and about 9,600–9,700 sq ft of meeting/event space across many rooms.

Best Western Gettysburg — branded accommodations with many accessible room types and in-room microwaves/refrigerators.
Hotel Gettysburg is on Lincoln Square and is the closer option for downtown shops and short walks to small museums and theaters.
Best Western Gettysburg publishes a complimentary full breakfast; Hotel Gettysburg’s on-site breakfast (One Lincoln) is not included and is charged separately.
Best Western Gettysburg lists an indoor pool. Hotel Gettysburg’s official FAQ states it does not have a pool.
Hotel Gettysburg — it offers a historic Grand Ballroom and extensive meeting/event space suited to weddings and conferences.
Explore how Hotel Gettysburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·